close
menu
dark_mode
person
Login
Create Account
Bobcat Attack Menu
Basketball
Basketball News
Schedule/Results
Recruiting
Football
Football News
Schedule/Results
Recruiting
Message Board
Message Home
Basketball
Basketball Recruiting
Football
Football Recruiting
The O Zone
Volleyball
Baseball
Ohio Olympic Sports
General OU Discussion
Website Feedback
Posting Policy
Chat
Site Links
Site Search
About Us
Contact Us
Site Help
Privacy Policy
Terms of Service
Basketball
Basketball News
Schedule/Results
Recruiting
Football
Football News
Schedule/Results
Recruiting
Message Board
Message Home
Basketball
Basketball Recruiting
Football
Football Recruiting
The O Zone
Volleyball
Baseball
Ohio Olympic Sports
General OU Discussion
Website Feedback
Posting Policy
Chat
Site Links
More...
Site Search
About Us
Contact Us
Site Help
Privacy Policy
Terms of Service
dark_mode
person
Login
Create Account
General Ohio University Discussion/Alumni Events Topic
Message Home
General Ohio University Discussion/Alumni Events
Topic:
Housing-gate continues
Page:
1
of
15
Alan Swank
General User
AS
Member Since:
12/11/2004
Location:
Athens, OH
Post Count:
7,387
AS
mail
Alan Swank
mail
Posted:
8/31/2015
6:20 PM
This just in:
http://www.athensnews.com/news/campus/state-inspector-gen...
Last Edited: 8/31/2015 6:21:41 PM by Alan Swank
add_reaction
React
👍 Like
👎 Dislike
❤️ Love
😡 Angry
🤣 Haha
😯 Wow
😢 Sad
Recovering Journalist
General User
RJ
Member Since:
8/17/2010
Location:
Cleveland, OH
Post Count:
1,864
RJ
mail
Recovering Journalist
mail
Posted:
12/7/2015
7:56 AM
And another.
http://www.athensnews.com/news/campus/inspector-general-w...
add_reaction
React
👍 Like
👎 Dislike
❤️ Love
😡 Angry
🤣 Haha
😯 Wow
😢 Sad
Alan Swank
General User
AS
Member Since:
12/11/2004
Location:
Athens, OH
Post Count:
7,387
AS
mail
Alan Swank
mail
Posted:
12/7/2015
2:30 PM
Recovering Journalist
wrote:
expand_more
And another.
http://www.athensnews.com/news/campus/inspector-general-w...
I see where one of our regular posters and former trustees is mentioned in this report. Just provide the info, tell the truth and let's move on folks. This has gone on for over a year now.
add_reaction
React
👍 Like
👎 Dislike
❤️ Love
😡 Angry
🤣 Haha
😯 Wow
😢 Sad
Athens
General User
Member Since:
12/20/2004
Location:
Alexandria, VA
Post Count:
5,496
mail
Athens
mail
Posted:
12/8/2015
3:27 AM
It's the handling of housing gate by the administration that's been the problem. They had negotiated a price with a local business man for a property they valued. A price above appraised value but it was negotiated between the university and the owner. The owner at one time had a conversation with the athletic department that when he sells his house he'll catch up on back pledges and $200,000 additional contribution. Media finds out and the administration buckles to pressure and backs off on the purchase yet leaves the president renting the house. OIG is notified and wants to review the correspondence and the administration hands over redacted information. If the owner was to donate to the school and receive commercial benefit then its self dealing. A donation + home sale are two separate non-commercial exchanges. The administration should have executed the deal and take questions later.
Most Memorable Bobcat Events Attended
2010 97-83 win over Georgetown in NCAA 1st round
2012 45-13 victory over ULM in the Independence Bowl
2015 34-3 drubbing of Fiami @ Peden with 25,086 fans
2023 10-7 near shutout of Iowa State @ Solich Field
2025 17-10 defeat of WVU @ Peden in front of 26,740
add_reaction
React
👍 Like
👎 Dislike
❤️ Love
😡 Angry
🤣 Haha
😯 Wow
😢 Sad
Bobcatbob
General User
Member Since:
12/21/2004
Location:
Coolville, OH
Post Count:
1,353
mail
Bobcatbob
mail
Posted:
12/9/2015
11:18 AM
Uncle Wes
wrote:
expand_more
...If the owner was to donate to the school and receive commercial benefit then its self dealing. A donation + home sale are two separate non-commercial exchanges. The administration should have executed the deal and take questions later.
I'm not sure how a home sale constitutes a non-commercial exchange but, regardless, are you saying that the the Foundation should have gone ahead with the purchase even after the minimal known facts were discovered?
My own belief is that the "handling" should have started with the McDavis', Golding, the Foundation and even Jim Schaus running away from Wharton as fast as they could. Keeping this thing alive by honoring the lease is only the most recent mis-step and one I find baffling. Who are they trying to impress by playing this thing as wholly above board and who is ever going to believe them even if it's true?
add_reaction
React
👍 Like
👎 Dislike
❤️ Love
😡 Angry
🤣 Haha
😯 Wow
😢 Sad
Alan Swank
General User
AS
Member Since:
12/11/2004
Location:
Athens, OH
Post Count:
7,387
AS
mail
Alan Swank
mail
Posted:
12/9/2015
4:39 PM
Uncle Wes
wrote:
expand_more
It's the handling of housing gate by the administration that's been the problem. They had negotiated a price with a local business man for a property they valued. A price above appraised value but it was negotiated between the university and the owner. The owner at one time had a conversation with the athletic department that when he sells his house he'll catch up on back pledges and $200,000 additional contribution. Media finds out and the administration buckles to pressure and backs off on the purchase yet leaves the president renting the house. OIG is notified and wants to review the correspondence and the administration hands over redacted information. If the owner was to donate to the school and receive commercial benefit then its self dealing. A donation + home sale are two separate non-commercial exchanges. The administration should have executed the deal and take questions later.
There is a big difference between a contribution where something is expected in return and a donation where one gives something of value without expectation or consideration or benefit. The fact you only get an 80% deduction on obc contributions bears that out unless you choose to forgo all benefits associated with you money that you are giving. Return benefits were expected in this case for every dollar given.
add_reaction
React
👍 Like
👎 Dislike
❤️ Love
😡 Angry
🤣 Haha
😯 Wow
😢 Sad
bobcat695
General User
B695
Member Since:
12/20/2004
Location:
Parkersburg, WV
Post Count:
1,345
B695
mail
bobcat695
mail
Posted:
12/10/2015
8:54 AM
There is zero chance I would ever pursue a high-level job in academia. This public argument shows how ignorant people can be about basic financial matters.
There was a housing issue that needed addressed, and a long-time supporter of the university had a property available for immediate occupancy that met all of their needs. (Virtually every successful person in Athens can be classified as a long-time supporter of Ohio University.) Using property tax assessment records to determine fair market value is absurd since those values are highly discounted and used for tax purposes only. Plus, the home was furnished. There are virtually no comps in Athens at that price point either. If people want to complain about a complete waste of OU's money spent on real estate, they should start with Punchcard Park.
If the OU Foundation (which is run by a bunch of visionary, successful people) thought it was a fair deal, then they should be trusted to make that decision. Is the next step for the public to start insisting on having a say in the investment management decisions of the Foundation's portfolio? I'll start by suggesting 50% in JCPenny stock/30% in a Greece REIT/20% in gold. Those are all cheap right now, which is how most of the vocal, editorial complainers think things should be solved.
"You can't un-fist a fist pump." - Saul Phillips 1/24/15
add_reaction
React
👍 Like
👎 Dislike
❤️ Love
😡 Angry
🤣 Haha
😯 Wow
😢 Sad
BillyTheCat
General User
BTC
Member Since:
10/6/2012
Post Count:
10,860
BTC
mail
BillyTheCat
mail
Posted:
12/12/2015
8:55 AM
Can't we all just get along.
Last Edited: 12/12/2015 9:05:20 AM by BillyTheCat
add_reaction
React
👍 Like
👎 Dislike
❤️ Love
😡 Angry
🤣 Haha
😯 Wow
😢 Sad
Alan Swank
General User
AS
Member Since:
12/11/2004
Location:
Athens, OH
Post Count:
7,387
AS
mail
Alan Swank
mail
Posted:
1/25/2016
2:17 PM
bobcat695
wrote:
expand_more
There is zero chance I would ever pursue a high-level job in academia. This public argument shows how ignorant people can be about basic financial matters.
There was a housing issue that needed addressed, and a long-time supporter of the university had a property available for immediate occupancy that met all of their needs. (Virtually every successful person in Athens can be classified as a long-time supporter of Ohio University.) Using property tax assessment records to determine fair market value is absurd since those values are highly discounted and used for tax purposes only. Plus, the home was furnished. There are virtually no comps in Athens at that price point either. If people want to complain about a complete waste of OU's money spent on real estate, they should start with Punchcard Park.
If the OU Foundation (which is run by a bunch of visionary, successful people) thought it was a fair deal, then they should be trusted to make that decision. Is the next step for the public to start insisting on having a say in the investment management decisions of the Foundation's portfolio? I'll start by suggesting 50% in JCPenny stock/30% in a Greece REIT/20% in gold. Those are all cheap right now, which is how most of the vocal, editorial complainers think things should be solved.
Not sure this was a fair deal. Any lease agreement I've ever read includes taxes and maintenance in it. Apparently not this one.
http://www.thepostathens.com/news/ohio-university-provide...
add_reaction
React
👍 Like
👎 Dislike
❤️ Love
😡 Angry
🤣 Haha
😯 Wow
😢 Sad
rpbobcat
General User
R
Member Since:
4/28/2006
Location:
Rochelle Park, NJ
Post Count:
3,670
R
mail
rpbobcat
mail
Posted:
1/26/2016
7:06 AM
Alan Swank
wrote:
expand_more
bobcat695
wrote:
expand_more
There is zero chance I would ever pursue a high-level job in academia. This public argument shows how ignorant people can be about basic financial matters.
There was a housing issue that needed addressed, and a long-time supporter of the university had a property available for immediate occupancy that met all of their needs. (Virtually every successful person in Athens can be classified as a long-time supporter of Ohio University.) Using property tax assessment records to determine fair market value is absurd since those values are highly discounted and used for tax purposes only. Plus, the home was furnished. There are virtually no comps in Athens at that price point either. If people want to complain about a complete waste of OU's money spent on real estate, they should start with Punchcard Park.
If the OU Foundation (which is run by a bunch of visionary, successful people) thought it was a fair deal, then they should be trusted to make that decision. Is the next step for the public to start insisting on having a say in the investment management decisions of the Foundation's portfolio? I'll start by suggesting 50% in JCPenny stock/30% in a Greece REIT/20% in gold. Those are all cheap right now, which is how most of the vocal, editorial complainers think things should be solved.
Not sure this was a fair deal. Any lease agreement I've ever read includes taxes and maintenance in it. Apparently not this one.
http://www.thepostathens.com/news/ohio-university-provide...
Depends on the lease.
I lease the building where I have my office.
I have to pay for all maintaince and minor repairs plus property taxes.
I'm sure if you don't,it just increases the monthly rent.
add_reaction
React
👍 Like
👎 Dislike
❤️ Love
😡 Angry
🤣 Haha
😯 Wow
😢 Sad
MedinaCat
General User
MC
Member Since:
12/20/2004
Location:
Lakewood, OH
Post Count:
750
MC
mail
MedinaCat
mail
Posted:
1/26/2016
8:38 AM
At the very least I would expect the front doors to be painted some shade of bobcat green.
add_reaction
React
👍 Like
👎 Dislike
❤️ Love
😡 Angry
🤣 Haha
😯 Wow
😢 Sad
Alan Swank
General User
AS
Member Since:
12/11/2004
Location:
Athens, OH
Post Count:
7,387
AS
mail
Alan Swank
mail
Posted:
1/31/2016
1:37 PM
rpbobcat
wrote:
expand_more
Alan Swank
wrote:
expand_more
bobcat695
wrote:
expand_more
There is zero chance I would ever pursue a high-level job in academia. This public argument shows how ignorant people can be about basic financial matters.
There was a housing issue that needed addressed, and a long-time supporter of the university had a property available for immediate occupancy that met all of their needs. (Virtually every successful person in Athens can be classified as a long-time supporter of Ohio University.) Using property tax assessment records to determine fair market value is absurd since those values are highly discounted and used for tax purposes only. Plus, the home was furnished. There are virtually no comps in Athens at that price point either. If people want to complain about a complete waste of OU's money spent on real estate, they should start with Punchcard Park.
If the OU Foundation (which is run by a bunch of visionary, successful people) thought it was a fair deal, then they should be trusted to make that decision. Is the next step for the public to start insisting on having a say in the investment management decisions of the Foundation's portfolio? I'll start by suggesting 50% in JCPenny stock/30% in a Greece REIT/20% in gold. Those are all cheap right now, which is how most of the vocal, editorial complainers think things should be solved.
Not sure this was a fair deal. Any lease agreement I've ever read includes taxes and maintenance in it. Apparently not this one.
http://www.thepostathens.com/news/ohio-university-provide...
Depends on the lease.
I lease the building where I have my office.
I have to pay for all maintaince and minor repairs plus property taxes.
I'm sure if you don't,it just increases the monthly rent.
Agreed and this is very common for commercial space. Residential space in Athens is quite a different story particularly in what is a fairly new home.
add_reaction
React
👍 Like
👎 Dislike
❤️ Love
😡 Angry
🤣 Haha
😯 Wow
😢 Sad
Recovering Journalist
General User
RJ
Member Since:
8/17/2010
Location:
Cleveland, OH
Post Count:
1,864
RJ
mail
Recovering Journalist
mail
Posted:
2/29/2016
8:18 AM
http://www.athensnews.com/news/campus/confirmed-ou-under-...
add_reaction
React
👍 Like
👎 Dislike
❤️ Love
😡 Angry
🤣 Haha
😯 Wow
😢 Sad
rpbobcat
General User
R
Member Since:
4/28/2006
Location:
Rochelle Park, NJ
Post Count:
3,670
R
mail
rpbobcat
mail
Posted:
2/29/2016
10:19 AM
Maybe its me,but when any Government agency requires documents to be submitted to them,that's an "investigation".
Reading the State's January 2016 letter,it seems they are merely expanding their records request to include emails.
Taken on its face,the request doesn't say much,other then asking for additional documents.
You can read into it whatever you want.
add_reaction
React
👍 Like
👎 Dislike
❤️ Love
😡 Angry
🤣 Haha
😯 Wow
😢 Sad
Bobcatbob
General User
Member Since:
12/21/2004
Location:
Coolville, OH
Post Count:
1,353
mail
Bobcatbob
mail
Posted:
3/1/2016
1:35 PM
When this kind of thing happens to political candidates, they send the money back to bolster the perception that they want no part of the controversy. As painful as that might be, this could be a case where that should be happening.
Each year, I get a nice brochure from the AD telling me what is expected of me as a donor/booster/fan/Bobcat so I don't cause an NCAA scandal. I don't know that the NCAA rules explicitly cover "publicly embarrassing the University, the Board, the President, the Athletic Director and his staff" but they probably should.
I also understand (don't I?) that the latest, promised $200K was never paid but I can't decide if that is more damning or less.
Besides all that, I have to think that the only good thing about this so far is that the Dispatch or some Columbus TV station hasn't assigned an "investigative" reporter to get to the bottom of this.
add_reaction
React
👍 Like
👎 Dislike
❤️ Love
😡 Angry
🤣 Haha
😯 Wow
😢 Sad
Alan Swank
General User
AS
Member Since:
12/11/2004
Location:
Athens, OH
Post Count:
7,387
AS
mail
Alan Swank
mail
Posted:
3/1/2016
3:41 PM
Bobcatbob
wrote:
expand_more
When this kind of thing happens to political candidates, they send the money back to bolster the perception that they want no part of the controversy. As painful as that might be, this could be a case where that should be happening.
Each year, I get a nice brochure from the AD telling me what is expected of me as a donor/booster/fan/Bobcat so I don't cause an NCAA scandal. I don't know that the NCAA rules explicitly cover "publicly embarrassing the University, the Board, the President, the Athletic Director and his staff" but they probably should.
I also understand (don't I?) that the latest, promised $200K was never paid but I can't decide if that is more damning or less.
Besides all that, I have to think that the only good thing about this so far is that the Dispatch or some Columbus TV station hasn't assigned an "investigative" reporter to get to the bottom of this.
NCAA rules only pertain to violations that involve athletes. This had nothing to do with athletes so it is nothing the NCAA will even be looking at. As state employees we are looking at possible ethics violations and the corresponding penalties.
add_reaction
React
👍 Like
👎 Dislike
❤️ Love
😡 Angry
🤣 Haha
😯 Wow
😢 Sad
The Optimist
General User
Member Since:
3/16/2007
Location:
CLE
Post Count:
5,615
mail
The Optimist
mail
Posted:
3/1/2016
6:51 PM
Alan Swank
wrote:
expand_more
Bobcatbob
wrote:
expand_more
When this kind of thing happens to political candidates, they send the money back to bolster the perception that they want no part of the controversy. As painful as that might be, this could be a case where that should be happening.
Each year, I get a nice brochure from the AD telling me what is expected of me as a donor/booster/fan/Bobcat so I don't cause an NCAA scandal. I don't know that the NCAA rules explicitly cover "publicly embarrassing the University, the Board, the President, the Athletic Director and his staff" but they probably should.
I also understand (don't I?) that the latest, promised $200K was never paid but I can't decide if that is more damning or less.
Besides all that, I have to think that the only good thing about this so far is that the Dispatch or some Columbus TV station hasn't assigned an "investigative" reporter to get to the bottom of this.
NCAA rules only pertain to violations that involve athletes. This had nothing to do with athletes so it is nothing the NCAA will even be looking at. As state employees we are looking at possible ethics violations and the corresponding penalties.
I recall at least one article from the A-News somehow tying in Wharton's donation to the Academic Center.
I've seen crazier things happen.
add_reaction
React
👍 Like
👎 Dislike
❤️ Love
😡 Angry
🤣 Haha
😯 Wow
😢 Sad
Bobcatbob
General User
Member Since:
12/21/2004
Location:
Coolville, OH
Post Count:
1,353
mail
Bobcatbob
mail
Posted:
3/2/2016
9:50 AM
Alan Swank
wrote:
expand_more
NCAA rules only pertain to violations that involve athletes. This had nothing to do with athletes so it is nothing the NCAA will even be looking at. As state employees we are looking at possible ethics violations and the corresponding penalties.
Yes, and what I mean to say is that we impose all these restrictions on donors when the NCAA is looking over our shoulder but somehow this stink is OK because athletes aren't directly involved? I'm throwing the bu&^%$#! flag on that. Leadership starts at the top.
add_reaction
React
👍 Like
👎 Dislike
❤️ Love
😡 Angry
🤣 Haha
😯 Wow
😢 Sad
D.A.
General User
DA
Member Since:
8/6/2010
Location:
Georgetown, ME
Post Count:
1,198
DA
mail
D.A.
mail
Posted:
3/2/2016
4:48 PM
The Optimist
wrote:
expand_more
Alan Swank
wrote:
expand_more
Bobcatbob
wrote:
expand_more
When this kind of thing happens to political candidates, they send the money back to bolster the perception that they want no part of the controversy. As painful as that might be, this could be a case where that should be happening.
Each year, I get a nice brochure from the AD telling me what is expected of me as a donor/booster/fan/Bobcat so I don't cause an NCAA scandal. I don't know that the NCAA rules explicitly cover "publicly embarrassing the University, the Board, the President, the Athletic Director and his staff" but they probably should.
I also understand (don't I?) that the latest, promised $200K was never paid but I can't decide if that is more damning or less.
Besides all that, I have to think that the only good thing about this so far is that the Dispatch or some Columbus TV station hasn't assigned an "investigative" reporter to get to the bottom of this.
NCAA rules only pertain to violations that involve athletes. This had nothing to do with athletes so it is nothing the NCAA will even be looking at. As state employees we are looking at possible ethics violations and the corresponding penalties.
I recall at least one article from the A-News somehow tying in Wharton's donation to the Academic Center.
From the articles, assuming you can believe the reporting, the commitment was (paraphrasing): When I (Wharton) sell this house I own, I will have the free cash flow to pay my outstanding pledge to the Walter of $100k in full, and will also have the free cash flow to make an additional donation in full for $100k to the Sook.
The Few, The Proud, The Bobcats!
And for the record, I hate tOSU, and Ricordati and Torgerson are DB's.
"This isn't just another walkover from the MAC." Kirk Herbstreit, another DB, on College Football Gameday
Last Edited: 3/2/2016 4:49:20 PM by D.A.
add_reaction
React
👍 Like
👎 Dislike
❤️ Love
😡 Angry
🤣 Haha
😯 Wow
😢 Sad
Alan Swank
General User
AS
Member Since:
12/11/2004
Location:
Athens, OH
Post Count:
7,387
AS
mail
Alan Swank
mail
Posted:
3/3/2016
6:27 PM
D.A.
wrote:
expand_more
The Optimist
wrote:
expand_more
Alan Swank
wrote:
expand_more
Bobcatbob
wrote:
expand_more
When this kind of thing happens to political candidates, they send the money back to bolster the perception that they want no part of the controversy. As painful as that might be, this could be a case where that should be happening.
Each year, I get a nice brochure from the AD telling me what is expected of me as a donor/booster/fan/Bobcat so I don't cause an NCAA scandal. I don't know that the NCAA rules explicitly cover "publicly embarrassing the University, the Board, the President, the Athletic Director and his staff" but they probably should.
I also understand (don't I?) that the latest, promised $200K was never paid but I can't decide if that is more damning or less.
Besides all that, I have to think that the only good thing about this so far is that the Dispatch or some Columbus TV station hasn't assigned an "investigative" reporter to get to the bottom of this.
NCAA rules only pertain to violations that involve athletes. This had nothing to do with athletes so it is nothing the NCAA will even be looking at. As state employees we are looking at possible ethics violations and the corresponding penalties.
I recall at least one article from the A-News somehow tying in Wharton's donation to the Academic Center.
From the articles, assuming you can believe the reporting, the commitment was (paraphrasing): When I (Wharton) sell this house I own, I will have the free cash flow to pay my outstanding pledge to the Walter of $100k in full, and will also have the free cash flow to make an additional donation in full for $100k to the Sook.
Wow! And I bet you think one of the three stooges "debating" on tv tonight is fit to be president. This was a pay to play deal if I ever saw one.
add_reaction
React
👍 Like
👎 Dislike
❤️ Love
😡 Angry
🤣 Haha
😯 Wow
😢 Sad
D.A.
General User
DA
Member Since:
8/6/2010
Location:
Georgetown, ME
Post Count:
1,198
DA
mail
D.A.
mail
Posted:
3/3/2016
9:44 PM
Alan Swank
wrote:
expand_more
D.A.
wrote:
expand_more
The Optimist
wrote:
expand_more
Alan Swank
wrote:
expand_more
Bobcatbob
wrote:
expand_more
When this kind of thing happens to political candidates, they send the money back to bolster the perception that they want no part of the controversy. As painful as that might be, this could be a case where that should be happening.
Each year, I get a nice brochure from the AD telling me what is expected of me as a donor/booster/fan/Bobcat so I don't cause an NCAA scandal. I don't know that the NCAA rules explicitly cover "publicly embarrassing the University, the Board, the President, the Athletic Director and his staff" but they probably should.
I also understand (don't I?) that the latest, promised $200K was never paid but I can't decide if that is more damning or less.
Besides all that, I have to think that the only good thing about this so far is that the Dispatch or some Columbus TV station hasn't assigned an "investigative" reporter to get to the bottom of this.
NCAA rules only pertain to violations that involve athletes. This had nothing to do with athletes so it is nothing the NCAA will even be looking at. As state employees we are looking at possible ethics violations and the corresponding penalties.
I recall at least one article from the A-News somehow tying in Wharton's donation to the Academic Center.
From the articles, assuming you can believe the reporting, the commitment was (paraphrasing): When I (Wharton) sell this house I own, I will have the free cash flow to pay my outstanding pledge to the Walter of $100k in full, and will also have the free cash flow to make an additional donation in full for $100k to the Sook.
Wow! And I bet you think one of the three stooges "debating" on tv tonight is fit to be president. This was a pay to play deal if I ever saw one.
What about "assuming you can believe the reporting" wasn't clear to you?
The Few, The Proud, The Bobcats!
And for the record, I hate tOSU, and Ricordati and Torgerson are DB's.
"This isn't just another walkover from the MAC." Kirk Herbstreit, another DB, on College Football Gameday
add_reaction
React
👍 Like
👎 Dislike
❤️ Love
😡 Angry
🤣 Haha
😯 Wow
😢 Sad
rpbobcat
General User
R
Member Since:
4/28/2006
Location:
Rochelle Park, NJ
Post Count:
3,670
R
mail
rpbobcat
mail
Posted:
3/4/2016
7:00 AM
Quote:
expand_more
Wow! And I bet you think one of the three stooges "debating" on tv tonight is fit to be president. This was a pay to play deal if I ever saw one.
No question,3 of the debaters came off very badly last night.
But do you honestly think that Laurel,everything will be free,and Hardy,orange jump suits will make me look thinner,are any better ?
Last Edited: 3/4/2016 9:08:31 AM by Ryan Carey
add_reaction
React
👍 Like
👎 Dislike
❤️ Love
😡 Angry
🤣 Haha
😯 Wow
😢 Sad
The Optimist
General User
Member Since:
3/16/2007
Location:
CLE
Post Count:
5,615
mail
The Optimist
mail
Posted:
3/4/2016
9:07 AM
D.A.
wrote:
expand_more
Alan Swank
wrote:
expand_more
D.A.
wrote:
expand_more
The Optimist
wrote:
expand_more
Alan Swank
wrote:
expand_more
Bobcatbob
wrote:
expand_more
When this kind of thing happens to political candidates, they send the money back to bolster the perception that they want no part of the controversy. As painful as that might be, this could be a case where that should be happening.
Each year, I get a nice brochure from the AD telling me what is expected of me as a donor/booster/fan/Bobcat so I don't cause an NCAA scandal. I don't know that the NCAA rules explicitly cover "publicly embarrassing the University, the Board, the President, the Athletic Director and his staff" but they probably should.
I also understand (don't I?) that the latest, promised $200K was never paid but I can't decide if that is more damning or less.
Besides all that, I have to think that the only good thing about this so far is that the Dispatch or some Columbus TV station hasn't assigned an "investigative" reporter to get to the bottom of this.
NCAA rules only pertain to violations that involve athletes. This had nothing to do with athletes so it is nothing the NCAA will even be looking at. As state employees we are looking at possible ethics violations and the corresponding penalties.
I recall at least one article from the A-News somehow tying in Wharton's donation to the Academic Center.
From the articles, assuming you can believe the reporting, the commitment was (paraphrasing): When I (Wharton) sell this house I own, I will have the free cash flow to pay my outstanding pledge to the Walter of $100k in full, and will also have the free cash flow to make an additional donation in full for $100k to the Sook.
Wow! And I bet you think one of the three stooges "debating" on tv tonight is fit to be president. This was a pay to play deal if I ever saw one.
What about "assuming you can believe the reporting" wasn't clear to you?
I almost felt about adding a similar statement to my post when I mentioned A-News...
I take everything I read their with a certain grain of salt. They present some interesting stories that other Athens papers miss out on but sometimes it feels very tabloid-like in that they seem to just throw stuff around to drum up views and see what sticks...
I've seen crazier things happen.
add_reaction
React
👍 Like
👎 Dislike
❤️ Love
😡 Angry
🤣 Haha
😯 Wow
😢 Sad
Recovering Journalist
General User
RJ
Member Since:
8/17/2010
Location:
Cleveland, OH
Post Count:
1,864
RJ
mail
Recovering Journalist
mail
Posted:
3/4/2016
9:34 AM
Attacking the messenger (in this case, the A-News) is such a lazy cop out when one doesn't like the implications of a story. A blanket statement of how "the media sucks" or journalists lie is just another ad hominem attack. Most people on this thread aren't even in Athens, yet they question the validity of these stories just based on the source. I don't know enough to say that they've had flawless reporting, but I've read all the stories and they have done the basics, including repeatedly trying to get the administration's side of the story both through interviews and FOIA requests. I get that many fans don't like the implications of this story, but trying to tear down the source doesn't change the basic realities of the case.
A McMansion on Coventry Lane could not possibly be worth $1.2 million on any open market. The most expensive Zillow estimate on Coventry right now is $338,000. The most expensive house for sale in all of Athens is less than $600,000 now. The stonewalling on information since it all came to light is not exactly a sign that everything was on the up and up either. I'm as big a fan as anyone, but I am with Alan on this one until the administration offers a better explanation.
Last Edited: 3/4/2016 9:35:52 AM by Recovering Journalist
add_reaction
React
👍 Like
👎 Dislike
❤️ Love
😡 Angry
🤣 Haha
😯 Wow
😢 Sad
The Optimist
General User
Member Since:
3/16/2007
Location:
CLE
Post Count:
5,615
mail
The Optimist
mail
Posted:
3/4/2016
10:49 AM
Recovering Journalist
wrote:
expand_more
Attacking the messenger (in this case, the A-News) is such a lazy cop out when one doesn't like the implications of a story. A blanket statement of how "the media sucks" or journalists lie is just another ad hominem attack. Most people on this thread aren't even in Athens, yet they question the validity of these stories just based on the source. I don't know enough to say that they've had flawless reporting, but I've read all the stories and they have done the basics, including repeatedly trying to get the administration's side of the story both through interviews and FOIA requests. I get that many fans don't like the implications of this story, but trying to tear down the source doesn't change the basic realities of the case.
A McMansion on Coventry Lane could not possibly be worth $1.2 million on any open market. The most expensive Zillow estimate on Coventry right now is $338,000. The most expensive house for sale in all of Athens is less than $600,000 now. The stonewalling on information since it all came to light is not exactly a sign that everything was on the up and up either. I'm as big a fan as anyone, but I am with Alan on this one until the administration offers a better explanation.
A blanket statement defending all journalists is much lazier than what I posted.
As I mentioned, the A-News does post some interesting stories that go missed by the Messenger and the Post. Why? In many cases, I think they cover a different type of story than those two outlets do... More of a tabloid type vibe trying to stir up controversy. In SOME cases, the controversy turns out to be warranted. I didn't draw this conclusion about the A-News based on this one story... In fact I think this one story is one of the better cases of investigative journalism they have done.
I believe it is OCF who pointed out that the A-News tends to re-hash the same articles year after year... As far as quality reporting goes, I'd put them below the Messenger in the Athens market. There is nothing wrong with that... The Messenger is a subscription based paper... The A-News is a free paper that generates revenue a different way... NOTHING wrong with that. Tabloids serve as a valuable entertainment outlet in this country.
I've seen crazier things happen.
add_reaction
React
👍 Like
👎 Dislike
❤️ Love
😡 Angry
🤣 Haha
😯 Wow
😢 Sad
Unread Messages Remain
There are more unread messages in this topic.
Would you like to jump to the next unread message or return to the message listing?
Next Unread
Back to Listing
Login Required
You must be logged in to do that.
Login
Create Account
Cancel
Topic Locked
Close
Image
Message Board Administration
Post Title:
Posted by User:
Post Name:
Real Name:
Email Address:
Post Date Time:
Post Location:
IP Address:
Resolves to:
Location:
3rd Party Lookup
Delete Item:
This Post Only
Entire Topic
Delete
Pinned Topic:
Pinned End Date/Time or leave blank to manually remove pinned status later
Move Topic:
Move Topic
Locked Topic:
Move Topic
Also post a notice in the old forum saying where this topic was moved to?
Cancel
Confirm Delete
Cancel
Showing Messages:
1
-
25
of
354
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
Next
View Other General Ohio University Discussion/Alumni Events Topics
reply
vertical_align_top
vertical_align_center
vertical_align_bottom
add_comment
chevron_forward
MAC News Links
chevron_left
Saturday,
October 17, 2026
chevron_right
Who's Online
There are
97
Active Visitors on BobcatAttack.com
95 Guests
2 Registered Users:
Ryan Carey
,
Turdhats
User Login
Enter your login email and password below.
Email Address:
Password:
Forgot your password?
Login
Cancel
Don't have an account?
Sign Up
Create Account
Enter an email and password to get started. We'll send you a confirmation email - once you click the link in it, you can finish setting up your profile.
Email Address:
Password:
Confirm Password:
Create Account
Cancel
Already have an account?
Login
Forgot Password
Enter your email address and we'll send you a link to reset your password.
Email Address:
Send Reset Link
Cancel
User Profile
Loading...
mail
Send Private Message
block
Block This User
Post Name History
Post Name
Changed
Profile Picture
Message Board Posting Policy
Loading...
Login Required
You must be logged in to do that.
Login
Create Account
Cancel
Complete Your Profile
Before you can post to the message board, please complete the following on your profile:
Go to My Profile
Cancel
hourglass_top
Please Wait
One moment…
error
Something went wrong
If it keeps happening, please mention this reference number:
Photo