close
menu
dark_mode
person
Login
Create Account
Bobcat Attack Menu
Basketball
Basketball News
Schedule/Results
Recruiting
Football
Football News
Schedule/Results
Recruiting
Message Board
Message Home
Basketball
Basketball Recruiting
Football
Football Recruiting
The O Zone
Volleyball
Baseball
Ohio Olympic Sports
General OU Discussion
Website Feedback
Posting Policy
Chat
Site Links
Site Search
About Us
Contact Us
Site Help
Privacy Policy
Terms of Service
Basketball
Basketball News
Schedule/Results
Recruiting
Football
Football News
Schedule/Results
Recruiting
Message Board
Message Home
Basketball
Basketball Recruiting
Football
Football Recruiting
The O Zone
Volleyball
Baseball
Ohio Olympic Sports
General OU Discussion
Website Feedback
Posting Policy
Chat
Site Links
More...
Site Search
About Us
Contact Us
Site Help
Privacy Policy
Terms of Service
dark_mode
person
Login
Create Account
Ohio Football Topic
Message Home
Ohio Football
Topic:
Redshirt question
Page:
1
of
1
Kevin Finnegan
General User
KF
Member Since:
2/4/2005
Location:
Rockton, IL
Post Count:
1,230
KF
mail
Kevin Finnegan
mail
Posted:
10/27/2020
2:37 PM
In the last couple of seasons, the redshirt restrictions were adjusted. I think last year, a player could appear in four games and still be redshirted for the season. With the shortened season this year, is that number adjusted to a lower level? What impact do you think the redshirt rules will have on the season?
add_reaction
React
👍 Like
👎 Dislike
❤️ Love
😡 Angry
🤣 Haha
😯 Wow
😢 Sad
rpbobcat
General User
R
Member Since:
4/28/2006
Location:
Rochelle Park, NJ
Post Count:
3,670
R
mail
rpbobcat
mail
Posted:
10/27/2020
2:45 PM
The NCAA has ruled this Fall season doesn't count, as far as eligibility, no matter how many games a team/person plays.
All Fall athletes automatically get another year of eligibility.
add_reaction
React
👍 Like
👎 Dislike
❤️ Love
😡 Angry
🤣 Haha
😯 Wow
😢 Sad
bobcatsquared
General User
B
Member Since:
12/20/2004
Post Count:
5,924
B
mail
bobcatsquared
mail
Posted:
10/27/2020
5:44 PM
Does this apply to every player/team?
For example, if Ian Book plays 14 games as a fifth-year senior quarterback at Notre Dame, the potential max # of games for the Irish, it doesn't count against his eligibility?
I mean, I can see the reason for some situations. But in my example, I'm not sure I'm in agreement.
Last Edited: 10/27/2020 5:45:04 PM by bobcatsquared
add_reaction
React
👍 Like
👎 Dislike
❤️ Love
😡 Angry
🤣 Haha
😯 Wow
😢 Sad
rpbobcat
General User
R
Member Since:
4/28/2006
Location:
Rochelle Park, NJ
Post Count:
3,670
R
mail
rpbobcat
mail
Posted:
10/27/2020
6:48 PM
bobcatsquared
wrote:
expand_more
Does this apply to every player/team?
For example, if Ian Book plays 14 games as a fifth-year senior quarterback at Notre Dame, the potential max # of games for the Irish, it doesn't count against his eligibility?
I mean, I can see the reason for some situations. But in my example, I'm not sure I'm in agreement.
From what I've read,the NCAA is giving an extra year of eligibility to all Fall athletes,whether they play or not,and regardless of how many games they play.
You can read all the details on si.com
I know the NCAA did the same thing for Winter sports like wrestling.
Don't think it includes basketball.
add_reaction
React
👍 Like
👎 Dislike
❤️ Love
😡 Angry
🤣 Haha
😯 Wow
😢 Sad
UpSan Bobcat
General User
Member Since:
8/30/2005
Location:
Upper Sandusky, OH
Post Count:
3,820
mail
UpSan Bobcat
mail
Posted:
10/27/2020
8:32 PM
bobcatsquared
wrote:
expand_more
Does this apply to every player/team?
For example, if Ian Book plays 14 games as a fifth-year senior quarterback at Notre Dame, the potential max # of games for the Irish, it doesn't count against his eligibility?
I mean, I can see the reason for some situations. But in my example, I'm not sure I'm in agreement.
Right, he could play again next year, but he'd have to maintain NCAA eligbility to do so. Most guys, especially ones who already are on their fifth year, probably will be ready to move on in life, but not always. Some might be able to work on grad degrees.
add_reaction
React
👍 Like
👎 Dislike
❤️ Love
😡 Angry
🤣 Haha
😯 Wow
😢 Sad
bobcatsquared
General User
B
Member Since:
12/20/2004
Post Count:
5,924
B
mail
bobcatsquared
mail
Posted:
10/27/2020
10:13 PM
Will this be the rare NCAA rule that benefits the non-power conference teams like Ohio? I can see a trickle down effect where players from power conference teams seeing their playing time in jeopardy and enter the transfer portal for a chance at more playing time at a non-power conference team. Or is that just wishful thinking?
add_reaction
React
👍 Like
👎 Dislike
❤️ Love
😡 Angry
🤣 Haha
😯 Wow
😢 Sad
ExCat21
General User
EC21
Member Since:
9/29/2014
Post Count:
1,269
EC21
mail
ExCat21
mail
Posted:
10/28/2020
5:38 PM
This will benefit teams who have a lot of redshirt seniors. I know there are a lot of downfalls of the 2020 virus but there are some positives:
1. Seniors get extra year for pros
2. Grads can work towards Masters.
3. Transfers get extra opportunity to showcase talent.
4. New high-ranking recruits like WW3 will be a beast by his senior year. Essentially he gets 6 games (maybe 7 or 8 depending on our record) for free that don't count towards his eligibility. So no redshirt for anybody this year really. I think everyone plays.
5. With conferences facing their peers, teams can't pad their wins playing lower-tiered conferences. So there's more on the line and one team can drop or rise significantly with a signature loss/win. Indiana is a prime example (who I predicted we will play in Quick Lane). Penn State and Michigan State has some ground to make as well with a loss to Rutgers. And PSU plays OSU this week so they could be 0-2 quickly. This will open up doors for higher G5 teams to play better bowl games this year. (IE- Cincinnati Bearcats as well as the top MAC and WAC teams).
If you were on a bowl committee that had to decide between a top MAC team or a middle of the road P5, would you take a 5-1 Ohio Bobcats team or a 3-3 Syracuse Orangemen team?
add_reaction
React
👍 Like
👎 Dislike
❤️ Love
😡 Angry
🤣 Haha
😯 Wow
😢 Sad
BillyTheCat
General User
BTC
Member Since:
10/6/2012
Post Count:
10,860
BTC
mail
BillyTheCat
mail
Posted:
10/28/2020
6:59 PM
ExCat21
wrote:
expand_more
This will benefit teams who have a lot of redshirt seniors. I know there are a lot of downfalls of the 2020 virus but there are some positives:
1. Seniors get extra year for pros
2. Grads can work towards Masters.
3. Transfers get extra opportunity to showcase talent.
4. New high-ranking recruits like WW3 will be a beast by his senior year. Essentially he gets 6 games (maybe 7 or 8 depending on our record) for free that don't count towards his eligibility. So no redshirt for anybody this year really. I think everyone plays.
5. With conferences facing their peers, teams can't pad their wins playing lower-tiered conferences. So there's more on the line and one team can drop or rise significantly with a signature loss/win. Indiana is a prime example (who I predicted we will play in Quick Lane). Penn State and Michigan State has some ground to make as well with a loss to Rutgers. And PSU plays OSU this week so they could be 0-2 quickly. This will open up doors for higher G5 teams to play better bowl games this year. (IE- Cincinnati Bearcats as well as the top MAC and WAC teams).
If you were on a bowl committee that had to decide between a top MAC team or a middle of the road P5, would you take a 5-1 Ohio Bobcats team or a 3-3 Syracuse Orangemen team?
You must have missed the part where wins have been waved for bowl games.
And if you are on a Bowl committee you are looking at tickets and hotel rooms.
Last Edited: 10/28/2020 7:01:41 PM by BillyTheCat
add_reaction
React
👍 Like
👎 Dislike
❤️ Love
😡 Angry
🤣 Haha
😯 Wow
😢 Sad
ExCat21
General User
EC21
Member Since:
9/29/2014
Post Count:
1,269
EC21
mail
ExCat21
mail
Posted:
10/29/2020
1:02 AM
I sure did. Thanks for that. But the .500 requirement still exists. So hopefully we will see more 2-4, 3-4 or in the Big 10s case, 4-5 records. Not sure if they will play 9 games with Wisconsin's situation right now.
add_reaction
React
👍 Like
👎 Dislike
❤️ Love
😡 Angry
🤣 Haha
😯 Wow
😢 Sad
BillyTheCat
General User
BTC
Member Since:
10/6/2012
Post Count:
10,860
BTC
mail
BillyTheCat
mail
Posted:
10/29/2020
11:14 AM
Actually NO they did not get rid of the .500 requirement!
Under ordinary circumstances, teams must have a .500 record to qualify for a bowl game (sometimes a 5-7 team will get a bowl bid if there aren’t enough .500 teams), but the Football Oversight Committee recommended getting rid of that rule for the current season, as the effects of the COVID-19 pandemic continue to linger and cause the postponement and cancellation of games.
https://sports.yahoo.com/ncaa-waives-win-requirements-for...
Last Edited: 10/29/2020 11:17:22 AM by BillyTheCat
add_reaction
React
👍 Like
👎 Dislike
❤️ Love
😡 Angry
🤣 Haha
😯 Wow
😢 Sad
GoCats105
General User
GC105
Member Since:
1/31/2006
Location:
Seattle, WA
Post Count:
7,861
GC105
mail
GoCats105
mail
Posted:
10/29/2020
2:41 PM
bobcatsquared
wrote:
expand_more
Will this be the rare NCAA rule that benefits the non-power conference teams like Ohio? I can see a trickle down effect where players from power conference teams seeing their playing time in jeopardy and enter the transfer portal for a chance at more playing time at a non-power conference team. Or is that just wishful thinking?
Actually I can see the opposite happening. The 5th year senior who played at a Group of Five and there is a roster spot open on a Power Five and they want to elevate their draft status playing against stiffer competition.
Power Fives would be dumb to take a freshmen when they could take a seasoned vet for a one year rental if they're trying to win right now.
add_reaction
React
👍 Like
👎 Dislike
❤️ Love
😡 Angry
🤣 Haha
😯 Wow
😢 Sad
Unread Messages Remain
There are more unread messages in this topic.
Would you like to jump to the next unread message or return to the message listing?
Next Unread
Back to Listing
Login Required
You must be logged in to do that.
Login
Create Account
Cancel
Topic Locked
Close
Image
Message Board Administration
Post Title:
Posted by User:
Post Name:
Real Name:
Email Address:
Post Date Time:
Post Location:
IP Address:
Resolves to:
Location:
3rd Party Lookup
Delete Item:
This Post Only
Entire Topic
Delete
Pinned Topic:
Pinned End Date/Time or leave blank to manually remove pinned status later
Move Topic:
Move Topic
Locked Topic:
Move Topic
Also post a notice in the old forum saying where this topic was moved to?
Cancel
Confirm Delete
Cancel
Showing Messages:
1
-
11
of
11
View Other Ohio Football Topics
reply
vertical_align_top
vertical_align_center
vertical_align_bottom
add_comment
MAC News Links
chevron_left
Saturday,
October 17, 2026
chevron_right
Who's Online
There are
103
Active Visitors on BobcatAttack.com
102 Guests
1 Registered User:
Bobcat Love's Sense of Shame
User Login
Enter your login email and password below.
Email Address:
Password:
Forgot your password?
Login
Cancel
Don't have an account?
Sign Up
Create Account
Enter an email and password to get started. We'll send you a confirmation email - once you click the link in it, you can finish setting up your profile.
Email Address:
Password:
Confirm Password:
Create Account
Cancel
Already have an account?
Login
Forgot Password
Enter your email address and we'll send you a link to reset your password.
Email Address:
Send Reset Link
Cancel
User Profile
Loading...
mail
Send Private Message
block
Block This User
Post Name History
Post Name
Changed
Profile Picture
Message Board Posting Policy
Loading...
Login Required
You must be logged in to do that.
Login
Create Account
Cancel
Complete Your Profile
Before you can post to the message board, please complete the following on your profile:
Go to My Profile
Cancel
hourglass_top
Please Wait
One moment…
error
Something went wrong
If it keeps happening, please mention this reference number:
Photo