Sporting News put out their list for awards for each Division 1 basketball conference and DJ was their pick for POY in the MAC.  
http://aol.sportingnews.com/ncaa-basketball/story/2011-03-09/sporting-news-2010-11-all-conference-lists 

How is Trey Zeigler first team all-MAC?  I wonder how many conference games these writers actually watched.

They probably haven't seen any. It's more than likely just an analysis of stats. I don't think anyone who actually watched a fair share of games would put Zeigler on the first team considering his shooting percentages, turnovers and his team's poor record. He's going to be good, but he certainly has a lot of improving to do.